'Luther' back on BBC America

Monday, 02 September 2013 04:55 PM Written by 

Luther series 3

BBC America’s “Luther” (10 p.m. Tuesday) returns this week for a four-episode third season that features violent, terrifying crimes as detective chief inspector John Luther (Idris Elba) also fights for his career as a retired cop teams with Erin Gray (Nikki Amuka-Bird) to try to bring Luther down.

The retired cop is a fairly bland, Javert-like mustache twirler but the bond Erin develops with Luther’s partner, Justin Ripley (Warren Brown), adds a nice wrinkle.

Luther remains a near-genius detective still haunted by his own demons, including the murder of his wife and his own anger management issues.

Read more after the jump. ...

As enjoyable as “Luther” has been through its first two seasons, “Luther” does seem to suffer from a case of diminishing returns. Luther has a new love interest this season, Mary Day (Sienna Guillory), but she’s not particularly interesting and she becomes even less interesting once wily serial killer Alice Morgan (Ruth Wilson) pops up again in the fourth episode. Alice, a distaff Hannibal Lecter, and Luther had a strong bond in the show’s first season and it was hugely disappointing that she was absent from season two.

In season three, it’s quite a long slog to get to Alice’s return. There’s a lot of barbarism and sadism to wade through to get to the fun character stuff that Alice brings. Initially, Alice seemed just as important to the show as Luther, and while it made some sense that writer Neil Cross couldn’t go to the Alice Morgan well too often – leaving her out of season two was probably necessary since she’s a criminal, albeit a criminal who shares a strong chemistry with Luther – you have to wonder if she’s back in season three, why stick her in just the final episode?

The first two episodes (10 p.m. Tuesday, 9 p.m. Wednesday) tell one crime story; episodes three (10 p.m. Thursday) and four (10 p.m. Friday) tell another story, this one of a vigilante seeking vengeance against violent criminals after his wife is murdered.

Elba remains a magnetic presence but as with all damaged heroes, Luther presents a problem for drama writers: Heal him and he’s less interesting; perpetuate his damage and the show gets repetitive. “Luther” seems stuck in the latter cycle.

It’s a relief to learn this is the final season of “Luther,” though reports suggest a prequel movie may be in the works. Maybe it’s also time to proceed with that proposed Alice Morgan spin-off series. Then Luther can be the special guest star in Alice’s sure-to-be demented stories.

Join the conversation:

To report inappropriate comments, abuse and/or repeat offenders, please send an email to socialmedia@post-gazette.com and include a link to the article and a copy of the comment. Your report will be reviewed in a timely manner. Thank you.