A Beatles (Book Review) Outtake

Monday, 14 October 2013 03:00 PM Written by 

My review of Larry Kane's third Beatles book ran Sunday. As sometimes happens with any story, things get excised for space. Since one edit left out a point I wanted to get across, this is the full, unedited version.  I've added a link to my previous blog entry on the Freda Kelly documentary.



By Larry Kane

(Running Press)

$ 24.95

By Rich Kienzle

Larry Kane, the future dean of Philly news anchors, was the 21-year-old News Director of Miami's WFUN radio in 1964, when he became an embedded reporter on tour with the Beatles. His reports of their 1964-65 US tours were syndicated to over 40 stations, experience that gave him a close-up perspective on Beatlemania's peak years.

His connections with all four and their inner circle continued long after the 1970 breakup.  He chronicled those two years in the excellent 2003 memoir "Ticket To Ride," which offered great insights into the Beatles' individual talents, foibles and humanity. He followed it with a 2005's "Lennon Revealed," exploring John Lennon's life.

Over time, the Beatles' stature as a musical, cultural and historical phenomenon has only grown. For years, most books about the group were superficial and fan-oriented until serious historians like Allan Kozinn, Mark Lewisohn and others raised the bar for Beatle scholarship.   

In that context, "When They Were Boys" makes perfect sense, probing the group's roots in Liverpool and Germany in the late 50's.  It ends as they explode on the American pop scene in 1964.  

Mr. Kane interviews and profiles individuals, most in Britain and Germany, involved with the band in the early days. He allows all to have their say, letting the reader judge their veracity. Some are well-known to Beatle fans and historians.

Bill Harry, the founder-editor of the pioneering Liverpool fan tabloid "Mersey Beat," covered the group when they were a local attraction. Sam Leach promoted their early gigs. Freda Kelly was Beatle manager Brian Epstein's secretary; Derek Taylor and Tony Barrow were the group's early publicists. 

Mr. Kane interweaves these newer accounts with quotes from his 60's interviews and post-breakup chats with ex-Beatles and those in their entourage.   He correctly notes that many he spoke with are "mere footnotes in the (Beatles') own history." That, however, may be changing. Ms. Kelly is the subject of the brand-new, Kickstarter-funded documentary "Good Ol' Freda."

The book's strengths include fascinating discussions of the group's beginnings as a skiffle group called the Quarrymen and their later period playing sleazy dives in Hamburg. George Harrison's sister Louise, a St. Louis resident in 1963, recalls her zeal to help the boys establish an American foothold, doggedly funneling data on the US market to Epstein in Britain before they ever set foot here.

Unfortunately, Mr. Kane's egalitarian interview approach sometimes trips him up. Allowing individuals to expound without perspective or context sometimes results in a rambling narrative, hobbled by quickly shifting perspectives and occasional editorial glitches. Individuals identified in previous chapters are often totally re-introduced. 

Too often, quotes include needless asides like "I want to tell you Larry…"  "Well, Larry..." and "It was my first job, Larry" that get old pretty fast.  We get it, Larry. They were talking to you.

Not synthesizing his information sometimes prevents him from connecting the dots. He discusses Epstein's homosexuality with great sensitivity and Lennon's drunken, brutal 1963 assault on his friend, Cavern Club disc jockey Bob Wooler at Paul McCartney's 20th birthday party.  Unfortunately, he never mentions what sparked Lennon's rage: Wooler's mocking, homophobic remarks about a recent Lennon-Epstein vacation trip.

This lack of critical scrutiny results in occasional accuracy issues.  Of her first meeting with Mimi Smith, Lennon's legendary "Aunt Mimi," at her Liverpool home in the late 60's, Yoko Ono noted Smith's husband George "was in a corner like no one could see him." Indeed. George Smith died in 1955; his wife never remarried.

The author digs into the band's controversial, poorly managed 1962 firing of original drummer Pete Best in favor of Ringo Starr.  Relying largely on the Best family's perspective, he offers hints that Mr. Best's bandmates resented his onstage charisma and quotes others--including Mr. McCartney--lauding Mr. Best's percussion skills.

While showing respect and affection for Mr. Starr, Mr. Kane overlooks a pivotal, established fact: the three who knew best, Lennon, Harrison and Mr. McCartney, considered Mr. Starr a far better musical and personal fit. History has vindicated that judgment many times over.  Mr. Best's drumming rocked; Mr. Starr could rock and roll, and that made all the difference. 

Mr. Kane has journalistic skills beyond debate. "Ticket To Ride" remains an essential first-person memoir. Historiography, however, requires a vastly different approach. "When They Were Boys" contains few stunning revelations, many of them synthesized elsewhere with greater panache. He can be proud of his Beatle connections and scholarship, but the results here don't always measure up.

Join the conversation:

To report inappropriate comments, abuse and/or repeat offenders, please send an email to socialmedia@post-gazette.com and include a link to the article and a copy of the comment. Your report will be reviewed in a timely manner. Thank you.